Best Mattresses

Mattress shopping is overwhelming. There are so many choices in retail stores and online, and every person has different preferences for how they like to sleep. We set out to find the best mattresses made in the U.S.A. to help ease that decision making process. Our top picks, additional product details, and research methodology are all below. Happy shopping!

Our Findings

We evaluated 53 mattress brands made in the U.S., and narrowed our top choices down to seven brands that we think are producing the highest quality mattresses for the best price. We evaluated each brand on several criteria, everything from price, to support, to motion isolation, and aeration for cooling purposes. Check out our top picks below.

Top Recommendations

Best MattressesBest for:
CasperSoft Memory Foam
Tuft & NeedleFirmer Memory Foam
Saatva Innerspring Mattress (Best Value)Innerspring
CRāVE Spring Hybrid MattressEco-Friendly
BearMattressMuscle Recovery
Zenhaven Latex MattressLatex
Colgate Evertrue EliteCribs

Recommendations: Going Deeper

Check out additional details about each of our top picks, what we liked, what we didn’t like, and the types of sleepers that will enjoy each of our recommendations.

Best Plush Memory Foam Mattress

Casper


Casper is a relatively new mattress manufacturer that was founded in 2013 and is headquartered in New York City. Their out of the box mattress was the best memory foam option we found that had a great plush comfort level. Foam for their mattresses are poured in facilities in Georgia and Pennsylvania. They also sew their covers and panels at factories in South Carolina and Illinois. The Casper mattress sleeps relatively cool, which is surprising for a memory foam mattress – the cover material is pretty breathable. The mattress has a lot of give to it, meaning if you like to sink into your mattress, this will be a good fit for you. Edge support is pretty good, so if you like sleeping at the edge of your bed, you likely won’t have the feeling that you’re going to fall off because the surface sinks so much. Overall, this is a great choice for anyone who wants a mattress with a good amount of give and wants to sleep cool.

Check Price on Amazon

Things we like:

  • 100 night trial period
  • 10 year warranty
  • Free shipping straight to your home

Things we don’t like:

  • Only one model to choose from

 

Best Firm Memory Foam Mattress

Tuft & Needle


Tuft & Needle is another up and coming mattress company founded in the last few years (2012). They are based in Phoenix, Arizona. They source their mattress fabrics from mills in the Carolinas, assemble mattresses in California, and also pour all their foam right here in the USA. The Tuft & Needle mattress was the best we found for memory foam mattresses that are on the firmer side. The cover is made with a Polyester/Tactel blend, which is super stretchy and thin, helping air flow freely through the mattress and keep you cool at night. The construction of this bed is a little different than the similar Casper memory foam mattress – it has no transition foam layer between the top comfort level and base layer, which results in a firmer feel. The Tuft & Needle mattress performs really well in many motion transfer tests, which means there isn’t a ton of disturbance across the mattress when your partner gets up in the middle of the night. Edge support is good with this mattress, so you can comfortably sleep at the end of the mattress without worrying about falling off. Overall, this is a great mattress for folks that like memory foam, but want a firmer surface with more support.

Check Price on Amazon

Things we like:

  • 100 night trial period
  • 10 year product warranty
  • Free shipping
  • Sleeps cool
  • Lower price than similar competitors

Things we don’t like:

  • Doesn’t come with a box spring

 

Best Innerspring Mattress

Saatva Innerspring Mattress (Best Value)


Saatva has roots all across the US, with factory operations in 12 states and fulfillment centers in even more. We think their innerspring mattresses are second to none, and also a phenomenal value at their current price. Saatva offers multiple firmness levels to appeal to a variety of different sleepers. The cover is made of 100% organic cotton, which is very breathable and soft. They do the small things too to help your sleeping experience, like a small extra strip of memory foam around the lumbar region to help with additional pressure relief. Coils inside the mattress are individually wrapped, which helps isolate motion on the bed so you don’t disturb your partner. The medium firmness of their base model is comfortable for a wide variety of sleepers, whether you like to sleep on your back or side. The Saatva also has incredible edge support, which makes sense given its innerspring construction. If you like a coil-based mattress with some good spring and support, the Saatva is a great option.

Check Price on Site

Things we like:

  • 120 night trial period
  • 15 year warranty
  • Variety of models to choose from based on your firmness preferences

Things we don’t like:

  • Shipping isn’t free

 

Best Eco-Friendly Mattress

CRāVE Spring Hybrid Mattress


CRāVE stood out among other mattresses when it comes to a blend of comfort and environmental friendliness. CRāVE mattresses are all made in North Carolina, and every single material that goes into them is sourced within a 220 mile radius of the factory, which reduces their carbon footprint. All soy-based foams for each mattress are CertiPur-US® certified, which means they are made without ozone depleters, flame retardants, heavy metals (like mercury and lead), formaldehyde, and phthalates regulated by the Consumer Product Safety Commission. CRāVE has four mattress types to choose from, two of which are spring hybrid mattresses. The poly nylon blend in the mattress cover is very breathable, and the layers underneath also help with temperature control. The CRāVE mattress has good support at various points across the mattress, including the edges. Coils in the mattress are also individually wrapped, which helps minimize motion transfer, although it still experiences some.

Check Price on Amazon

Things we like:

  • Locally sourced and made without harmful materials
  • 100 night trial
  • Free shipping
  • Low cost

Things we don’t like:

  • Some motion transfer

 

Best Mattress for Muscle Recovery

BearMattress


The Bear Mattress is specifically designed for people with an active lifestyle. It’s made with some unique materials that help with blood flow and muscle recovery, like the use of Celliant in its cover. Celliant is often found in sporting apparel and helps with muscle recovery by turning body heat into infrared light, which improves blood flow helping with oxygen circulation and keeping you cool throughout the night. If you sleep hot, this mattress is a great option to help reduce those fitful nights of tossing and turning. Just below the cover is a 1.5″ thick graphite infused memory foam layer, which is a material that isn’t used very often in other mattress companies, but helps with pressure relief and temperature control. The Bear Mattress does a good job or distributing weight for a variety of sleeper types. So, whether you’re on your back, side, or stomach, no areas of your body will likely experience high pressure. If you’re very active and want a mattress that helps you recover while you sleep, this is the mattress for you.

Check Price on Amazon

Things we like:

  • Unique materials that are uncommon among today’s mattresses
  • 100 night risk-free trial period
  • 10 year warranty
  • Free shipping within the continental U.S.
  • 1% of each sale is donated to the Good Sports Charity

Things we don’t like:

  • None

 

Best Latex Mattress

Zenhaven


Zenhaven is a fantastic all-natural latex mattress made by the online mattress company Saatva. Their mattresses are made with 100% natural American Talalay latex, and wrapped in organic wool and cotton that is super soft and breathable. The Zenhaven mattress is flippable, with 1.5″ thick comfort layers on both sides, and one side is a little bit firmer than the other, so you can have the ideal firmness according to your preferences. The contour of a latex mattress is a lot different than a popular memory foam or innerspring mattress – it doesn’t mold exactly to the contour of your body, however zones around the bed provide more support where you need it and less where you need more pressure relief. Cooling on latex mattresses is very good as latex doesn’t retain heat, so this is a great option for hot sleepers. The latex material also has a higher degree of bounce than other typical mattress materials. Overall, the Zenhaven is the best latex option we found and a great choice for anyone who wants a natural mattress with good bounce and great support.

Check Price on Site

Things we like:

  • Full service delivery
  • 20 year warranty
  • 120 night trial period
  • Organic materials
  • Great support

Things we don’t like:

  • Delivery costs $99

 

Best Baby Mattress for Cribs

Colgate Evertrue Elite


The Colgate Evertrue Elite baby mattress is the best crib mattress we found made right here in the USA. This mattress is made with a CertiPUR-US® certified safe viscoelastic memory foam that helps with pressure reduction and helps your baby sleep comfortably and safely. The memory foam adapts to your baby’s position, so they’re comfortable no matter what position they’re in. The Colgate Evertrue Elite also has SecureCore Technology™, which helps with air circulation around the mattress. To top it off, the mattress is covered with a Softtouch Caress cover that is hypoallergenic, waterproof, and tear resistant for long-lasting durability and comfort.

Check Price on Site

Things we like:

  • Made with safe materials
  • Plant oil based eco foam core
  • Contours to your baby’s sleeping position
  • Bed bug and dust mite proof

Things we don’t like:

  • None

Factors We Considered

Comfort

First and foremost, your mattress has to be comfortable. We looked for mattresses that are made with soft materials that appeal to a wide variety of sleepers. A good mattress has a sizeable comfort layer (at least 1.5 inches) at the top of the mattress to separate the sleeper from the base foam layers or inner springs.

Firmness

We looked for mattresses that had a wide variety of firmness options that appeal to everyone from the super plush to the super firm sleepers.

Breathable

Especially for hot sleepers, your mattress has to be very breathable. This concerns everything from the top cover to the base layers of foam underneath. Celliant and cotton are two popular cover materials that breathe very well. Underneath, the proper foam has to be installed to help with proper air flow.

Support

It’s one thing to select a certain firmness level, but proper support entails much more. Certain spots on the mattress require more support than others, which helps provide pressure relief at the right spots along your body. The good mattress manufacturers know these spots and add some extra foam support where needed. Edge support is also important for sleepers who need every inch of space on the mattress, and when you’re sitting at the edge of it in the mornings.

Bounce

Some sleepers like more bounce than others. Most of our choices have a middle of the road bounce level that appeals to most types of sleepers.

Motion Isolation

Motion isolation is super important to make sure that when you get up in the middle of the night, you don’t wake your partner. All of our top choices passed several consumer tests to make sure movement at certain points in the mattress don’t affect others.

Value

As always, we looked for the best mattresses for your money. We eliminated all mattresses where we felt the quality of the product didn’t live up to the price.

 

All American Reviews Team

We’re here to take the guesswork out of buying quality, American products and services.