Best Natural Toothpaste

Some toothpastes can contain harmful chemicals that can cause stomach unrest, ulcers, canker sores, and more unpleasant side-effects. That’s why we decided to put together a list of the best natural toothpaste brands made in the USA. Below are all of the findings from our research as well as an inside look at all of the factors we considered.

Our Findings

After looking through dozens of toothpaste options, we chose 7 brands that we thought were a cut above the rest: Davids, Dental Herb, Desert Essence, Earthpaste, My Magic Mud, RADIUS, and Tom’s of Maine. Toothpaste comes in several different varieties, so we split out our recommendations into several categories like vegan, charcoal, coconut oil, and a few others. Check out all of our recommendations below.

Top Recommendations

Best Natural ToothpasteBest for:
DavidsVegan Toothpaste
Dental Herb CompanyPrevent Bleeding Gums
Desert EssenceCoconut Oil Toothpaste
Earthpaste Lemon TwistFewest Ingredients
My Magic MudCharcoal Toothpaste
RADIUSKids’ Toothpaste
Tom’s of MaineWhitening Toothpaste

Recommendations: Going Deeper

Here are some deeper details about each of our top picks, including tons of features, what we liked, didn’t like, and where to get them.

Best Vegan Toothpaste

Davids


Davids is one of our favorite natural toothpaste brands because the company gets all the details just right. The toothpaste is free from sulfates and fluoride, but manages to fight plaque and whiten teeth at the same time. All the ingredients included in the toothpaste are listed on the website and the product is all-natural. We love that there aren’t any artificial sweeteners, preservatives, or flavors used. The toothpaste relies on calcium carbonate, baking soda, xylitol, and hydrated silica to effectively clean and protect the teeth. It’s a good solid formula and an excellent option when searching for healthy toothpaste.

Check Price

Things we like:

  • Whitens teeth
  • Fights plaque
  • EWG verified for safety
  • Fluoride and sulfate free
  • Nothing artificial
  • Uses a Vegan formula
  • Recyclable tube
  • Complete list of ingredients available

Things we don’t like:

  • Uses xylitol which can cause upset stomachs

 

Best Toothpaste to Prevent Bleeding Gums

Dental Herb Company


If you’re searching for a natural toothpaste that effectively inhibits gum bleeding, the Tooth and Gums Essentials paste made by the Dental Herb Company works surprisingly well. This product is a mix of essential oils like cinnamon, peppermint, and thyme to fight bacterial growth, as well as gotu kola, aloe vera, and echinacea to reduce gum bleeding and promote healing. This powerful paste will help build healthier teeth and should work well to reduce oral bacteria as well, though we wish it included baking soda for its abrasive cleaning ability.

Check Price

Things we like:

  • SLS free
  • Controls gum bleeding
  • No artificial ingredients
  • Use powerful essential oils to reduce bacteria
  • Uses gotu kola, echinacea and aloe vera to reduce bleeding
  • Fights bacterial growth with xylitol

Things we don’t like:

  • Features xylitol that might cause stomach unrest
  • Lacks baking soda

 

Best Coconut Oil Toothpaste

Desert Essence


Most people have heard of how beneficial coconut oil can be for tooth health because of its anti-bacterial properties. Desert Essence Coconut Oil toothpaste uses the powerful oil to create an effective cleaner for your teeth. The product relies on sea salt and baking soda to scrub away the grime. Then it uses a mix of Zinc Citrate and coconut oil to fend off sugars and bacteria over time. The toothpaste tastes good with a mild minty flavor and it helps the mouth feel clean for a surprisingly long time after use. The only downside is that if you like a lot of foaming action, this toothpaste doesn’t provide that.

Check Price

Things we like:

  • Prevents sugar acids from doing damage
  • Has Zinc Citrate to fend off gingivitis
  • Removes plaque and bacteria with coconut oil
  • Includes sea salt and baking soda

Things we don’t like:

  • Doesn’t foam as much as conventional tooth pastes

 

Toothpaste with the Fewest Ingredients

Earthpaste Lemon Twist


We’re impressed with Earthpaste’s Lemon Twist because the toothpaste has so few ingredients and still manages to do its job. The toothpaste works simply, it uses bentonite to remove debris and re-mineralize teeth. Sea salt is also included as a scrubbing agent. Other than that, the toothpaste includes xylitol to help fight bacteria and it has a blend of lemon, lime, and tangerine essential oils for flavor – and that’s it other than water. The paste has a clean pleasant taste and effectively scrubs and cleans teeth. It lacks some natural tools such as baking soda that many people rely on for serious bacteria fighting power though.

Check Price

Things we like:

  • Very limited ingredients
  • Features bentonite clay as a scrubber
  • Relies on Xylitol for an anti-bacterial
  • Infused with sea salt for scrubbing power
  • Features lemon, tangerine and lime essential oils for flavor

Things we don’t like:

  • Lacks baking soda and other common anti-bacterials

 

Best Charcoal Toothpaste

My Magic Mud


We really liked the function of My Magic Mud for its ability to whiten teeth and its unique appearance and texture. This black toothpaste comes in four different delicious flavors and it effectively scrubs teeth clean while keeping damaging plaque away in the process. The paste is made from activated charcoal that effectively scrubs and whitens teeth. It also comes with xylitol and coconut oil to fend of bacteria and features bentonite clay as an added scrubbing agent and a tool to remove any unwanted debris from the mouth. This paste is very different from standard toothpaste, but it’s been proven to whiten teeth effectively and does a good job keeping teeth clean as well.

Check Price

Things we like:

  • Naturally whitens teeth
  • Uses an activated charcoal base
  • Relies on xylitol to battle bacteria
  • Infused with helpful essential oils
  • Comes with bentonite clay
  • Four different flavor options
  • No fluoride or SLS

Things we don’t like:

  • Odd texture

 

Best Kids’ Toothpaste

RADIUS


Most natural toothpaste products aren’t designed for children, and it shows. They come in strong mint and spearmint flavors that many children don’t enjoy, and many are a bit harsher than standard toothpaste is with ingredients meant for optimal scrubbing. These can be good things, but not for children’s toothpaste. That’s why Radius is one of our favorites. The company offers a good tasting line of children’s toothpaste that’s not harsh, has a good flavor, and includes ingredients that help with tooth health while achieving effective cleaning. The paste uses coconut oil and citric acid for much of its cleaning power. It comes with aloe to soothe ailing gums and is free from SLS. The toothpaste is made with fully organic ingredients and includes agave as a sweetener. Radius offers several different flavors and has a few gel toothpaste options that are even more kid-friendly than their standard toothpaste.

Check Price

Things we like:

  • Fully organic ingredients
  • Kid-friendly flavors
  • SLS free
  • Sweetened with Agave
  • Cleans and whitens well

Things we don’t like:

  • Minimal foaming action

 

Best Whitening Toothpaste

Tom’s of Maine


Tom’s of Maine Luminous White toothpaste is an impressive product that manages to rely on mostly natural ingredients while reliably whitening teeth at the same time. The past includes hydrated silica to effectively polish, clean, and whiten teeth. It features Carrageenan as a helpful gum cleanser, and also includes xylitol, a known sweetener and anti-bacterial agent. The toothpaste is effective for cleaning your teeth and tastes pleasant at the same time. If you’re looking for the best natural whitener, this is it, but some people don’t like that the toothpaste contains sodium laurel sulfate and fluoride.

Check Price

Things we like:

  • Includes xylitol
  • Relies on carrageenan for gum health
  • Uses hydrated silica to scrub and clean

Things we don’t like:

  • Includes fluoride and SLS

Recap: Best Natural Toothpaste Made in the USA


Factors We Considered

Anti-Bacterial

One of the most important jobs of toothpaste is to fight away the harmful bacteria that leads to gingivitis and eventually gum disease. That’s why we looked closely at the formulas of each of our top-selected toothpaste brands and choose options with anti-bacterial properties. Some rely on specific essential oils, some coconut oil, and many xylitol, among others. We put a strong focus on finding options that would fight off harmful bacteria reliably.

Scrubbing and Whitening

A good toothpaste doesn’t just fight bad bacteria, it scrubs away plaque and other contaminants from the mouth. That’s why scrubbing agents like baking soda, clay, sea salt, and activated charcoal are included in most of our top selections. Many of these effective scrubbing agents work to whiten teeth as well.

All Natural

So many toothpastes used today have unhealthy chemicals and potentially harmful substances and it’s easy to use them without even thinking about it. That’s why we wanted to focus on toothpaste products made from all-natural ingredients. Each toothpaste listed above is made from natural ingredients and they avoid many of the more questionable chemicals such as artificial sweeteners, triclosan, artificial colors, and others. For other natural health products, check out our picks for the best CBD oil made in the USA.

Avoids Fluoride and Sodium Laurel Sulfate

Most of our recommendations also avoid fluoride and Sodium Lauryl Sulfate to make them more health conscious. Fluoride is thought to help fight tooth decay, but also comes with some undesirable side-effects, especially when ingested by children. Sodium Lauryl Sulfate is another ingredient that is best avoided because it can cause canker sores. We focused on toothpaste products that avoid these two ingredients for the most part, though they are found in the Tom’s of Maine product to get the extra whitening effect.

Tastes Good

While it’s not necessary for toothpaste to taste good, we tried to track down products that offer cleaning benefits while tasting good as well. It’s true you can get used to a poor flavor while brushing your teeth, but it’s much more enjoyable to use a paste that leaves a good taste in your mouth. Most achieve their flavor with essential oils, but some rely on coconut oil, xylitol, and other compounds for a pleasant taste.